| Name | Gender | Title | Season | Year |
| Journey Gurley | Women's | NCAA All-American (2nd team) | Outdoor | 2023 |
| Kenna Stimmel | Women's | NCAA All-American (2nd Team) | Outdoor | 2023 |
| Julia Fixsen | Women's | NCAA All-American (1st) | Outdoor | 2023 |
| Hayley Horvath | Women's | NCAA All-American (2nd Team) | Outdoor | 2023 |
| Journey Gurley | Women's | NCAA All-American (2nd team) | Indoor | 2023 |
| Kenna Stimmel | Women's | NCAA All-American (4th place) | Indoor | 2023 |
| Julia Fixsen | Women's | NCAA All-American (2nd team) | Indoor | 2023 |
| Julia Fixsen | Women's | NCAA All-American (5th place) | Outdoor | 2022 |
| Rachel Baxter | Women's | NCAA All-American (4th) | Outdoor | 2022 |
| Jacob Spotswood | Men's | NCAA All-American (Hep. 2nd Team) | Indoor | 2022 |
| Julia Fixsen | Women's | NCAA All-American (3rd place) | Indoor | 2022 |
| Rachel Baxter | Women's | NCAA All-American (1st Place) | Indoor | 2022 |
| Rachel Baxter | Women's | NCAA All-American (4th) | Indoor | 2021 |
| Deakin Volz | Men's | NCAA All-American (2nd Team) | Outdoor | 2019 |
| Deakin Volz | Men's | NCAA All-American (2nd Team) | Indoor | 2019 |
| Rachel Baxter | Women's | NCAA All-American (6th) | Indoor | 2019 |
| Deakin Volz | Men's | NCAA All-American (7th) | Outdoor | 2018 |
| Torben Laidig | Men's | NCAA All-American (3rd) | Outdoor | 2018 |
| Joel Leon-Benitez | Men's | NCAA All-American (8th) | Outdoor | 2018 |
| Lisa Gunnarsson | Women's | NCAA All-American (3rd) | Outdoor | 2018 |
| Rachel Baxter | Women's | NCAA All-American (T-4th) | Outdoor | 2018 |
| Deakin Volz | Men's | NCAA All-American (3rd) | Indoor | 2018 |
| Torben Laidig | Men's | NCAA 2nd Team All-American (13th) | Indoor | 2018 |
| Lisa Gunnarsson | Women's | NCAA All-American (4th) | Indoor | 2018 |
| Rachel Baxter | Women's | NCAA 2nd Team All-American (11th) | Indoor | 2018 |
| Brad Johnson | Men's | NCAA All-American (2nd Team) | Outdoor | 2017 |
| Torben Laidig | Men's | NCAA All-American (6th) | Indoor | 2017 |
| Deakin Volz | Men's | NCAA All-American (2nd Team) | Indoor | 2017 |
| Torben Laidig | Men's | NCAA All-American (2nd) | Outdoor | 2016 |
| Brad Johnson | Men's | NCAA All-American (2nd Team) | Outdoor | 2016 |
| Deakin Volz | Men's | NCAA All-American (Tie for 3rd) | Indoor | 2016 |
| Stephan Munz | Men's | NCAA 2nd Team All-American (16th) | Outdoor | 2014 |
| Torben Laidig | Men's | NCAA 2nd Team All-American (14th) | Outdoor | 2014 |
| Martina Schultze | Women's | NCAA All-American (3rd) | Outdoor | 2014 |
| Torben Laidig | Men's | NCAA All-American (6th) | Indoor | 2014 |
| Martina Schultze | Women's | NCAA All-American (7th) | Indoor | 2014 |
| Chris Uhle | Men's | NCAA All-American (2nd Team) | Outdoor | 2013 |
| Martina Schultze | Women's | NCAA All-American (8th) | Outdoor | 2013 |
| Martina Schultze | Women's | NCAA All-American (3rd) | Indoor | 2013 |
| Joe Davis | Men's | NCAA All-American (7th) | Outdoor | 2012 |
| Hunter Hall | Men's | NCAA 2nd Team All-American (16th) | Outdoor | 2012 |
| Martina Schultze | Women's | NCAA 2nd Team All-American (13th) | Outdoor | 2012 |
| Martina Schultze | Women's | NCAA All-American (7th) | Indoor | 2012 |
| Victoria von Eynatten | Women's | NCAA All-American (Tie - 8th) | Indoor | 2012 |
| Hunter Hall | Men's | NCAA 2nd Team All-American (12th) | Outdoor | 2011 |
| Joe Davis | Men's | NCAA All-American (8th) | Outdoor | 2011 |
| Hunter Hall | Men's | NCAA All-American (6th) | Indoor | 2011 |
| Jenia Olhovsky | Men's | NCAA All-American (8th) | Indoor | 2011 |
| Kelly Phillips | Women's | NCAA 2nd Team All-American (9th) | Indoor | 2011 |
| Jenia Olhovsky | Men's | NCAA All-American (8th) | Outdoor | 2010 |
| Jared Jodon | Men's | NCAA All-American (7th) | Outdoor | 2010 |
| Jenia Olhovsky | Men's | NCAA All-American (4th) | Indoor | 2010 |
| Jenia Olhovsky | Men's | NCAA All-American (4th) | Outdoor | 2009 |
| Hunter Hall | Men's | NCAA All-American (10th) | Outdoor | 2009 |
| Jenia Olhovsky | Men's | NCAA All-American (2nd) | Indoor | 2009 |
| Hunter Hall | Men's | NCAA All-American (7th) | Indoor | 2009 |
| Jenia Olhovsky | Men's | NCAA All-American (2nd) | Outdoor | 2008 |
| Kelly Phillips | Women's | NCAA All-American (6th) | Outdoor | 2008 |
| Jenia Olhovsky | Men's | NCAA All-American (5th) | Indoor | 2008 |
| Thorsten Mueller | Men's | NCAA All-American (7th) | Indoor | 2007 |
| Brian Mondschein | Men's | NCAA All-American (4th) | Outdoor | 2006 |
| Brian Mondschein | Men's | NCAA All-American (2nd) | Outdoor | 2005 |
| Brian Mondschein | Men's | NCAA All-American (5th) | Indoor | 2005 |
| Brian Hunter | Men's | NCAA All-American (3rd) | Indoor | 2000 |
| Bob Phillips | Men's | NCAA All-American (5th) | Outdoor | 1980 |
| Keith Neff | Men's | NCAA All-American (4th) | Indoor | 1976 |